Seminar in Natural Science

Analyzing Media Articles about Science

-- A Guide for Discussion and Writing -- 

General Questions:

• Characterize the general purpose of the article:  is it reporting on a new discovery? analyzing a scientific controversy or issue under debate? profiling the work of a scientist or group of scientists? explaining a basic concept? highlighting key questions raised by new data that have yet to be answered? other? a combination of the above? 
• Does it come to a definite conclusion, or is it more open-ended?
• Is the article informative, argumentative, or a combination of the two?  How does that affect the article's content and tone?  Does the article seem biased in any way?  If so, is that bias a detriment?  (Another way to get at this issue:  how objective is the article?)
• Consider the examples the author uses to support his/her main points.  Are they appropriate?  Which are the most effective, and why?  Do the examples raise any questions unacknowledged by the author?
• Examine the author's use of metaphors, analogies, or other comparisons.  How effective are they?  Do such literary devices complement or detract from the scientific basis of the article?  To what extent?
• What kinds of authorities or experts does the article cite?  How effectively are they used by the author?  Consider people, institutions, studies, historical documents, etc.  How much authority do they add to the article? 

Questions Related to the Scientific Method:

• Look at how the author discusses hypotheses, theories, data, observations, and/or experiments.  How much information is given?  What kinds of things are left out?  Are these omissions important or not?  Are you provided with enough data to make an informed judgment about the conclusions of cited research, or will you have to do more investigation by consulting other sources?
• Does the article comment on or characterize the scientific method?  If so, how?  What does it teach you about how science gets done, how experiments might be set up, how data is gathered, how theories are devised or changed, etc.?

Questions that Stimulate Reflection and Research:

• Does the author assume her readers will possess certain kinds of knowledge?  Do these assumptions impede your understanding of the article?  What do you need to know that you didn't know before?
• How does the information in the article correspond to your own knowledge of science?  Did you learn new things?  Did some items contradict your previous beliefs or knowledge?  Did the article, in general, seem accurate?  How does it correspond to what we've learned in our class about the scientific method, genetics, evolution, etc.?
• What sources does the article point provide, in case you'd like to do follow-up research?  How specific are these references?  How much credibility do they provide?

Assignments

Field Trips

Links

Schedule

Texts

391 Home Page 

mb's Courses Page
(classes / office hours)

mb's Home Page

Lobby of Roosevelt's Alfred A. Robin Campus (opened 1996)

Roosevelt's National Landmark, the Auditorium Building, downtown Chicago

The Gage Building: Roosevelt's Center for Professional Advancement (opened 2000) and another downtown landmark

Last updated 01/30/06